Stony Lake Toffee Company
What started as a small family tradition has grown into Stony Lake Toffee, named after the family’s favorite summer spot near Lake Michigan—a place full of love, memories, and sweet traditions.
Classic toffee flavors
Cathy’s Original Butterscotch
Dark Chocolate Sea Salt
White Chocolate Michigan Cherry
Award winning toffee
We are thrilled that Stony Lake Toffee was recognized in The International Chocolate Salon's 2024 Toffee Awards! Our Dark Chocolate Sea Salt flavor stood out as our most award-winning creation. Indulge in the ultimate treat: our premium buttery almond toffee, topped with rich dark chocolate, a sprinkle of finely chopped almonds, and a touch of coarsely ground sea salt. Perfect for the true dark chocolate connoisseur—shop now to enjoy it at home.
Special orders
Sweeten up your next special occasion or corporate event with a special order of our award winning Stony Lake Toffee! Our delicious toffee in a variety of sizes and flavors is perfect for wedding favors, gifts for out of town guests, or in gift baskets for holiday gifting. We can do custom labels as requested.
Follow us on social
Contact us
We'd love to hear from you! Whether you have questions about our award-winning toffee or need assistance with an order - we're here to help. Fill out the contact form, and one of our friendly team members will get back to you as soon as possible. Your feedback and inquiries are important to us, and we look forward to connecting with you!